Introduction
The world of revolvers is steeped in history and tradition, and few names carry as much weight and respect as Ruger. Ruger, known for its rugged and reliable firearms, has consistently delivered models that endure the test of time. Among their legendary offerings, the Ruger Redhawk and the Ruger Super Redhawk stand out. Both revolvers represent a commitment to power, durability, and a straightforward, no-nonsense approach to shooting. But which one reigns supreme? Choosing between the Ruger Redhawk and the Super Redhawk can be a difficult decision for firearm enthusiasts and those seeking a powerful sidearm. This detailed comparison will delve into their characteristics, helping you determine which model best suits your needs.
Historical Background and Development
A look back at the history of the revolver reveals a story of continuous innovation, and Ruger has played an essential role. Their dedication to producing robust firearms at competitive prices quickly made them a favorite. Their revolvers, frequently chambered for powerful cartridges, are often associated with outdoor adventures and the ability to handle demanding conditions. The Ruger Redhawk and the Super Redhawk are testaments to this heritage, each built to handle the rigors of high-powered ammunition and the demands of serious shooters.
The Ruger Redhawk
The Redhawk’s origin can be traced back to Ruger’s desire to produce a revolver capable of handling the increasingly popular and powerful .44 Magnum cartridge. It was conceived as a heavier, more durable alternative to existing revolvers, specifically designed to absorb the significant recoil generated by these potent rounds. The Redhawk, introduced in the mid-seventies, instantly became a favorite among hunters and target shooters who required a handgun with both power and reliability. Its sturdy, all-steel construction quickly earned it a reputation for being almost indestructible. From its inception, the Redhawk was designed to be simple and reliable, a firearm you could depend on in any situation.
The Ruger Super Redhawk
The Super Redhawk, evolving from the base design of the Redhawk, was introduced with a few key enhancements to cater to the increasing demand for even more powerful cartridges. Ruger saw the need for a revolver that could handle the .454 Casull and other ultra-powerful rounds. Its creation was a direct response to the growing popularity of these potent cartridges and the need for a revolver that could safely and effectively manage the recoil. The Super Redhawk builds on the core strengths of its predecessor while improving other elements. The Super Redhawk also featured a redesigned frame, further enhancing its ability to manage recoil.
Design and Features Comparison
At first glance, you’ll notice significant differences between the Ruger Redhawk and the Super Redhawk. These variations influence everything from their feel in your hand to how they perform at the range.
Frame and Construction
The Redhawk boasts a robust single-piece frame, constructed from high-quality steel. This design contributes to its overall strength and rigidity, making it capable of withstanding the pressures generated by powerful cartridges. The one-piece frame gives it a clean, traditional look that many shooters appreciate. The steel construction also makes the Redhawk a weighty firearm, which, while adding to its overall heft, aids significantly in absorbing recoil.
The Super Redhawk, in contrast, features an extended frame, often referred to as a “double-top strap” design. This innovative design strengthens the frame and facilitates the inclusion of integral scope rings. This feature is a significant advantage for shooters who prefer to mount optics for enhanced accuracy at longer ranges. The Super Redhawk’s frame is also built with the same level of quality, ensuring durability and longevity. The frame’s unique design provides a solid platform for the cylinder and barrel.
Cylinder
The Redhawk’s cylinder, also steel, is designed for reliability. The cylinder typically offers a robust design, and is designed to provide reliable function. Its capacity varies based on the cartridge chambered, often holding six rounds of .44 Magnum. The Redhawk’s cylinder locking mechanism uses a sturdy design.
The Super Redhawk, inheriting the same focus on durability, also utilizes a steel cylinder. But it comes with several significant modifications. The cylinder’s design and locking mechanism are engineered to manage the pressures of even more powerful cartridges. While chambered for some of the same cartridges as the Redhawk, the Super Redhawk is also capable of handling rounds like the .454 Casull. The Super Redhawk, because of its construction, is able to accommodate these ultra-powerful rounds safely.
Barrel
The barrel on the Redhawk is known for its robust construction. Barrel length options vary, typically ranging from shorter options to longer ones for hunting or target shooting. The barrel on the Redhawk is generally well-tapered, providing a good balance between handling and ballistic performance. The barrel is rigidly attached to the frame.
The Super Redhawk also provides a selection of barrel lengths. The most defining characteristic is the heavy barrel profile on the Super Redhawk. This heavier barrel enhances accuracy and helps to further mitigate recoil. A great advantage of the Super Redhawk is that it incorporates integral scope rings. These rings allow shooters to quickly and securely mount optics. This integral system enhances versatility and accuracy.
Sights
The sights on the Redhawk are typically adjustable, allowing shooters to fine-tune their point of aim. The adjustable rear sight and the easily replaceable front sight make it a highly adaptable option. The sights are generally well-suited for both hunting and target shooting.
The Super Redhawk also features adjustable sights, similar to the Redhawk. The major advantage of the Super Redhawk is the pre-drilled, integrated scope rings. These rings provide a stable and secure platform for mounting scopes. This is a major advantage for anyone prioritizing extended-range shooting.
Grips
The grips play a crucial role in how a revolver feels in your hand and how well you manage recoil. The Redhawk frequently comes with factory grips designed to provide a secure and comfortable grip. There are also ample aftermarket options available, allowing shooters to customize the feel and look of their revolver. Many shooters choose to swap out grips for something that better suits their hand size and shooting style.
The Super Redhawk provides a well-designed grip that is often favored by shooters. Like the Redhawk, aftermarket options are plentiful. The grips are typically designed to facilitate comfortable shooting even with powerful cartridges.
Overall Size and Weight
The Redhawk offers a balance of power and manageability. Its dimensions and weight, while substantial, are generally considered well-suited for extended carry and comfortable shooting. The steel frame contributes to the revolver’s heft, aiding in recoil absorption. The overall size is relatively compact compared to some larger-framed revolvers, making it suitable for a variety of applications.
The Super Redhawk is generally larger and heavier than the Redhawk. This increased size and weight are primarily due to its extended frame, heavier barrel, and integrated scope mounts. While the Super Redhawk may not be as easy to conceal, the added weight contributes to superior recoil management and facilitates the mounting of optics for enhanced long-range accuracy. The increased size and weight make the Super Redhawk less ideal for all-day carry but an excellent choice for specific applications such as hunting or target shooting where size and weight are less of a concern.
Performance and Handling
Managing recoil and achieving accurate shot placement are critical aspects to consider when comparing these revolvers. These factors are influenced by the design, construction, and overall ergonomics of the firearm.
Recoil Management
The Redhawk, with its all-steel construction and solid design, absorbs recoil relatively well. Many shooters find the Redhawk to be quite manageable.
The Super Redhawk takes recoil mitigation a step further with its heavier frame. The Super Redhawk’s grip design also helps in reducing perceived recoil. This is a benefit, particularly when shooting the .454 Casull or similar cartridges.
Accuracy
Accuracy is another key factor. The Redhawk is capable of excellent accuracy, especially when paired with quality ammunition. The barrel’s design helps to achieve consistent performance.
The Super Redhawk, with its heavy barrel profile and integrated scope mount, has a slight advantage in the accuracy department. The scope mount makes it easier to obtain enhanced precision at longer ranges.
Caliber Options
Both revolvers typically offer chambering for .44 Magnum, a popular and potent cartridge for a variety of applications. The Redhawk may also be found chambered in other calibers. The Super Redhawk is frequently chambered in the more powerful .454 Casull and .480 Ruger.
Shooting Experience
Both revolvers offer a compelling shooting experience. The Redhawk provides a balanced feel with a manageable recoil. The Redhawk is known for its simplicity.
The Super Redhawk, while slightly larger, is still generally comfortable. The recoil is tamed, and the integrated scope mounts enhance the shooting experience.
Pros and Cons
Redhawk
The Redhawk benefits from a simpler design and a traditional aesthetic. It’s also a favorite of many shooters. However, its frame is not as robust as the Super Redhawk, and it lacks integrated scope mounts.
Super Redhawk
The Super Redhawk, with its more robust design and integrated scope mounts, is a great option for long-range shooting. However, the Super Redhawk may be considered less aesthetically pleasing by some.
Applications and Intended Use
The Redhawk is well-suited for hunting medium to large game, target shooting, and personal defense. It’s a good all-around choice for shooters who appreciate a traditional design.
The Super Redhawk is ideally suited for hunting big game, particularly at longer ranges, due to its ability to mount scopes.
Price and Availability
You’ll find these revolvers at a range of prices. The Redhawk typically comes at a somewhat lower price point than the Super Redhawk. The Super Redhawk, due to its enhanced features and more complex design, is generally priced higher. Availability of different barrel lengths and configurations varies.
Conclusion
In conclusion, both the Ruger Redhawk and the Super Redhawk are excellent revolvers, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. The Redhawk is a classic, reliable, and capable revolver. The Super Redhawk offers enhanced features and improved recoil management. If you want the maximum power and long-range accuracy, then the Super Redhawk is the winner. If you like a simpler design, the Redhawk will serve you well. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. Both the Ruger Redhawk and Super Redhawk are excellent examples of Ruger’s commitment to quality, durability, and providing shooters with reliable and powerful firearms. Whether you’re hunting, target shooting, or simply enjoy the thrill of shooting powerful cartridges, these revolvers will provide you with years of dependable service.
