A Look Back at the Genesis of Compact Protection
Concealed carry handguns play a crucial role in personal protection, offering individuals a discreet means to defend themselves. The compact and concealable design of these firearms allows for easy carrying, making them suitable for everyday use. Within the realm of concealed carry pistols, the Ruger LC9 and its successor, the Ruger LC9s, have earned a strong reputation for their reliability and affordability. But how do these two pistols stack up against each other? This comprehensive guide dives deep into the Ruger LC9 vs Ruger LC9s comparison, examining every aspect from their internal mechanisms to their shooting characteristics, helping you determine which model best suits your concealed carry needs.
Unpacking the Original: Features of the Ruger LC9
Before delving into the core comparison, it’s essential to understand the origins of these firearms. The original Ruger LC9 emerged as Ruger’s response to the growing demand for ultra-compact, concealable 9mm handguns. Introduced to the market as a slim, easily concealable option, the LC9 quickly found favor with those seeking personal protection. This pistol offered a slim profile and lightweight design that allowed for easy concealment in a variety of carry methods. Its introduction was a significant step in making reliable 9mm power more accessible to a broader audience.
The original LC9, upon its release, boasted a host of notable features. The pistol’s specifications immediately catch the eye. Its dimensions, characterized by a narrow width and a relatively short length, are ideal for discreet concealment. The capacity typically holds a reasonable number of rounds within the magazine. The weight is also a key factor in its appeal, making it comfortable to carry throughout the day.
A defining feature of the original LC9 is its trigger mechanism. This double-action-only (DAO) system results in a long, deliberate trigger pull. This design choice was intended to enhance safety by requiring a firm and intentional pull to fire the weapon. The trigger itself can be quite heavy, requiring a noticeable amount of force to actuate.
Furthermore, the LC9 usually includes a manual safety. This safety mechanism provides an added layer of security, preventing accidental discharge. In addition to the manual safety, the LC9 often featured a magazine disconnect safety, ensuring that the pistol cannot be fired without a magazine inserted. Sights on the original LC9 were generally fixed or of a low-profile design, aimed at providing a clear sight picture without snagging on clothing during drawing. The overall grip and ergonomics were designed to provide a secure hold, however, the compact nature of the gun can make it slightly challenging for those with larger hands.
Advantages of the Original Ruger LC9
The original LC9 has several advantages, particularly for individuals prioritizing concealability. The slim profile and lightweight design enable easy concealment in various carrying methods, making it suitable for everyday carry. The affordability of the LC9 was another major draw, especially during its initial release and in the used market. This lower price point made it an attractive option for those looking for reliable personal protection without breaking the bank. The Ruger brand is also known for its generally reliable designs, which have been incorporated into the LC9. This simplicity is a key benefit for users seeking a straightforward and dependable firearm.
Shortcomings of the Original
Despite its advantages, the original LC9 has some notable drawbacks. The heavy and long trigger pull, while contributing to safety, can negatively impact accuracy. The need for a deliberate pull can affect the speed of follow-up shots and overall accuracy. The magazine capacity, compared to some competitors, may be considered slightly limited. The compact design, while advantageous for concealment, can also result in a snappy recoil. The reduced mass means that the felt recoil is more pronounced.
Introducing the Refinement: Overview of the Ruger LC9s
The Ruger LC9s emerged as Ruger’s response to address the criticisms of the original LC9. The primary goal was to improve the trigger mechanism, while maintaining the concealability and compact footprint of the original. The introduction of the LC9s marked a significant evolution in the series, offering a refined shooting experience.
Key Features of the LC9s
The LC9s shares many similarities with the original LC9, but there are important differences. The Ruger LC9s retains the same overall dimensions and weight, ensuring its continued suitability for concealed carry. The capacity of the magazines also tends to be quite similar between the two models.
The major change in the LC9s is the trigger mechanism. The LC9s adopted a striker-fired system. This change resulted in a much lighter and crisper trigger pull compared to the DAO trigger of the original. This improved trigger significantly enhanced the shooting experience. Manual safety mechanisms and the magazine disconnect safety (if present) were typically retained, maintaining the established safety features. Sights on the LC9s remained consistent with the original, offering the same sight picture. The grip and ergonomics were largely unchanged, providing a familiar feel to those familiar with the original.
Benefits of the Refinement: LC9s Advantages
The LC9s offers several advantages, making it a preferred choice for many. The improved trigger pull is arguably the most significant. The lighter and crisper trigger results in greater accuracy and faster follow-up shots. The LC9s continues to provide the concealability synonymous with the LC9. The improvements in the trigger enhance the overall shooting experience.
Considerations for the LC9s
Despite these improvements, the LC9s still has certain considerations. Due to its compact size, the recoil can feel more pronounced. Magazine capacity remains a similar consideration when compared to the original. While the striker-fired trigger is an improvement for many, those accustomed to hammer-fired pistols or those seeking a different trigger style might have a preference for something else.
Direct Comparison: Unveiling the Differences
To properly evaluate the Ruger LC9 vs Ruger LC9s, a direct comparison of several key aspects is essential.
Trigger Mechanism Showdown
The most fundamental difference lies in the trigger. The LC9 features a double-action-only trigger that is long, heavy, and requires considerable force to actuate. This trigger style can be challenging for those accustomed to lighter triggers. The LC9s employs a striker-fired system, resulting in a lighter, crisper, and shorter trigger pull. The difference in trigger pull weight and reset distance is significant. The LC9s provides a much cleaner break.
Impact on Shooting Experience
The trigger differences profoundly affect the shooting experience. With the LC9, shooters may struggle with consistent accuracy due to the heavy pull. The LC9s makes accurate shooting much easier, allowing for faster and more precise follow-up shots. The improved trigger generally makes the LC9s feel more enjoyable to shoot.
Ergonomics and Handling
While the overall dimensions of the pistols are similar, the grip and controls remain a factor. The grip texture, the placement of the controls, and the overall feel of the firearm contribute to how easily it can be handled and operated. The small size of these pistols might require adjustments to the way the shooter grips the gun. The LC9s typically presents the same ergonomic profile as the original.
Safety Measures
Both models generally incorporate safety features. Manual safeties, if present, offer an extra layer of protection. Magazine disconnect safeties further enhance safety by preventing firing if the magazine is removed. The effectiveness of these features depends on the shooter’s preference and training.
Reliability and Durability
Both the LC9 and LC9s are generally reliable pistols. Regular maintenance and proper care are essential for maintaining both pistols. Potential issues and the frequency of these problems should be a part of the purchasing decision.
Putting Them to the Test: Performance and Accuracy
The performance of the Ruger LC9 vs Ruger LC9s can be evaluated through range tests and practical use.
Accuracy Assessments
Accuracy testing involves shooting the pistols at a specified target distance to determine group sizes. The trigger pull, sights, and the shooter’s skill all influence accuracy. The enhanced trigger pull in the LC9s often translates to improved accuracy.
Real-World Applications
These handguns are intended for concealed carry and self-defense scenarios. The concealability, ease of use, and effectiveness in a defensive situation are important factors.
Advantages and Disadvantages: A Clear Breakdown
A direct comparison of the pros and cons of both pistols helps to clearly differentiate their key characteristics.
Choose Wisely: Which One is Right for You?
Selecting between the Ruger LC9 vs Ruger LC9s requires careful consideration of individual needs and preferences.
Considering the Original Ruger LC9
The original LC9 might be best suited for individuals prioritizing a low price point. Its simplicity and slim profile might also be considerations. The older models are also available in the used market.
Considering the Ruger LC9s
The Ruger LC9s would be a top choice for shooters seeking an improved trigger pull, a better shooting experience, and increased accuracy potential.
Weighing the Options
It’s crucial to factor in personal preferences, budget, and shooting experience when deciding. Try both pistols if possible to evaluate the feel of the trigger and how they fit in your hand. The availability of these firearms may also impact your choice.
Wrapping Up: Final Thoughts
Both the Ruger LC9 and Ruger LC9s offer compelling features for concealed carry. The LC9 provides an affordable, slim, and reliable option. The LC9s builds upon this foundation by introducing a vastly improved trigger mechanism, making it easier to shoot accurately and enjoy the shooting process.
By understanding the differences between these two models, you are well-equipped to make an informed decision. We recommend that you, if possible, visit your local gun range to try out each model before making your final purchase. This firsthand experience will help you choose the firearm that best aligns with your needs and personal preferences.
